How Much Difference Can A Letter Make?
Jacques Chambers, CLU, Benefits Consultant.
It’s complicating enough that Social Security operates two entirely separate disability benefit plans, and having their initials only one letter apart practically guarantees confusion. Yet one letter can be very important as there is a world of difference between the two plans. The two plans are SSI (Supplemental Security Income) and SSDI (Social Security Disability Insurance). Perhaps the best way to clear the confusion is to look at them together.
NOTE: This is an overview only to clarify the distinctions between SSI and SSDI. This is not intended to provide a comprehensive description of either plan.First, the concept and goal of each plan shows why there are major differences:
- SSI is a “needs-based” benefit. In addition to providing benefits to persons who are disabled of any age including children, it also pays monthly benefits to people over age 65 whether or not they are disabled. The key to SSI benefits is “financial need.” The “Financial Eligibility,” discussed below, is based on the person’s lack of personal resources and income to meet necessities of life. SSDI is also called SSD. Social Security calls it just “Disability” and refers to the DIB, or the Disability Insurance Benefit. Whatever it’s called (we’ll use SSDI), the program was created so workers who become disabled and unable to work to their normal retirement age will be able to access their Social Security retirement benefit early. Private pension plans would call this a “disability retirement” benefit.“ Financial eligibility,” discussed below, is solely based on the length of time and amount paid in F.I.C.A. payroll taxes.
There are some similarities between the plans:Both SSI and SSDI:
- Are administered by the federal Social Security Administration. Will pay a monthly benefit to totally disabled persons who qualify. Require the very same level of medical disability to qualify for benefits, and follow the same procedure in determining whether or not an applicant is disabled (See Social Security and HCV in Benefits Section of this site; it applies to both SSI and SSDI). Uhh……….That’s about it for similarities.
Now, the major differences:
Amount of Monthly Benefit
SSI pays a set amount each month. The amount will vary some depending on whether the beneficiary lives independently, lives in a board and care facility, has cooking facilities, lives rent-free, is blind, and several other factors.
A disabled person living alone in his/her own apartment with cooking facilities is eligible to receive up to $545 per month during 2002 from the federal government. However, SSI functions as a safety net, or a floor of income; any other income received is deducted from that SSI base amount.
Some states supplement the federal SSI payment with an additional payment raising the monthly payment. Check with your local Social Security office to see what your state does.
SSDI pays a monthly benefit based on the amount of F.I.C.A. payroll taxes the person has paid into Social Security over his/her working career. The benefit may be anywhere from one dollar per month to around $1,700 per month.
The calculation attempts to estimate what the retirement benefit would be if the person continued working to retirement and pay that amount as the SSDI monthly benefit.
Each year about three months before each person’s birthday, Social Security sends out a statement summarizing the F.I.C.A. taxes paid and estimated retirement benefits plus what the disability payment would be. Statements can also be requested at the Social Security website, http://www.ssa.gov.
These are the non-medical requirements for the benefits. One is based on what you “don’t have;” the other looks only at payroll taxes you paid.
SSI benefits are only available to persons who can show that they have very few assets or resources and low income.
Resources/Assets must be less than $2,000 ($3,000 for a married couple). This includes all money in checking, savings, as well as retirement savings accounts. It also includes real estate (except your home), stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and other investments. It does NOT include one car, the residence you live in, most personal property including furniture and clothing, and certain other exempt items.
Income is more complicated since it is related to the amount of SSI benefit you are eligible to receive and that varies. Generally, your income must be less than the amount of benefit you would be eligible to receive, and SSI will only pay the difference between your other income and the amount you would be entitled to receive based on your residence and living situation.
For example, if you would be eligible to receive $545 from SSI but your SSDI pays you $700 per month, you would not be eligible for any SSI benefit. However, if your
SSDI payment were only $300, you would be eligible for a partial payment from SSI that would take your total income up to approximately $545 per month.
SSDI financial eligibility is based solely on the Social Security (F.I.C.A.) payroll taxes you paid over your working career. It totally ignores how much money you do or don’t have. To be eligible for SSDI, you must have paid F.I.C.A. taxes in 20 out of the last 40 calendar quarters (five out of the last ten years). If you are under age 31, that number is reduced. If you are over age 42, the minimum number of quarters increases approximately one quarter for each year over age 42.
As long as you can meet the payroll tax payment requirement, you may receive SSDI benefits if you become totally disabled, regardless of what other income or wealth you may have.
When Monthly Payments Start
When monthly benefits start varies between the two plans.
SSI benefits start on the first of the month that you first submit your application, even if it takes several months to get approval.
For example, you submit your SSI application on April 14 and your claim is approved on July 25. Social Security will owe you benefits from April 1, which they will send you in a lump sum payment.
Once you are approved, SSI checks arrive on the first of each month.
SSDI benefits start in a totally different manner. First, you are not eligible to receive any SSDI benefits during the first five calendar months of your disability, regardless of when you apply for benefits.
For example, you stop working due to symptoms of HCV on February 14, 2002. You don’t get around to applying for SSDI benefits until September 3, 2002. On November 10, 2002, Social Security sends you a letter saying that you were approved for SSDI benefits and the Onset Date (the day they consider your total disability to have started) is February 15, 2002, the day after your last day of work. You would be eligible for benefits beginning August 1, 2002 (five calendar months after your Onset Date). You would receive a lump sum check for the benefits from August through November.
The regular monthly checks for SSDI come in the month following the month that you “earn” the benefit. Your SSDI check for April will come during May.
In most states, coverage for medical bills accompanies SSI and SSDI.
SSI will vary some by state, but in almost all states, you are eligible for Medicaid if you receive even one dollar from SSI. In most states, Medicaid comes automatically with approval for SSI benefits. In some states you must make separate application with your state’s Department of Human Services.
SSDI is accompanied by Medicare, the federal healthcare plan, regardless of what state you live in. However, a person receiving SSDI benefits does not become eligible for Medicare until they have received benefits for twenty-four months (29 months after date of disability counting the five month waiting period for SSDI benefits).
In the SSDI example above, the person who starts receiving SSDI benefits on August 1, 2002 will be eligible for Medicare on August 1, 2004.
Periodic Confirmation of Continued Eligibility for Benefits
Both plans will periodically re-examine your medical records to see if you are still totally disabled. The review to see if you are still disabled is called a Continuing Disability Review. It will occur every three to seven years, depending on the nature of your disability. For persons with HCV, the disability reviews will usually be from five to seven years apart.
SSI will review your financial records every year to see if you still qualify for SSI benefits. If your income or resources exceed their maximums, your benefits will stop.
SSDI has no ongoing review of financial eligibility. SSDI beneficiaries only have the Continuing Disability Reviews.
If you apply to Social Security for disability benefits, they are supposed to screen you for both SSI and SSDI. Just to be sure, if you find your SSDI is less than $1,000 per month, ask the representative about SSI to see if you might be eligible.
When you apply for SSI, in addition to medical records, Social Security will want to see financial records, including bank statements, lease and mortgage agreements, savings and other documentation of your financial status.
Confused about applying for disability? Click here
[Jacques Chambers, CLU, and his company, Chambers Benefits Consulting, have over 35 years of experience in health, life and disability insurance and Social Security disability benefits. For the past twelve years, he has been assisting people with their rights, problems, and other issues concerning benefits and disability. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org or through his website at: http://www.helpwithbenefits.com .]