How to Tell If You Have an Oversized Air Conditioner
It's been hot and muggy in Atlanta the past few days. Now I'm not your typical Atlantan who says that lightly. I grew up in Houston and south Louisiana and spent nine years in Florida, so I know hot and muggy. Overall, summers in Atlanta are pretty nice because of our elevation (
1000 feet), but we do have our moments.
Anyway, it's been hot enough that we've hit our summer design temperature. which is defined as the temperature exceeded only 1% of the time. In Atlanta, the summer design temperature is 92 degrees Fahrenheit. That's the temperature at which air conditioners ideally will provide exactly as much cooling as the house needs, when sized according to the Manual J cooling load calculation protocol developed by ACCA, the Air Conditioning Contractors of America.
When outdoor conditions are at the design temperature, an air conditioner should run pretty much continuously and be able to keep the house at the ACCA recommended indoor design temperature of 75 degrees Fahrenheit. When outdoor conditions go above the design temperature, the AC should run continuously and not quite keep the house at 75 degrees.
Now, the thing is, Manual J has some built in oversizing, so even if the air conditioner were sized according to an accurately performed Manual J load calculation, it's not going to run continuously at the summer design temperature. It should run long enough to make the house comfortable, however.
Last week I wrote about the 4 factors of comfort. temperature and humidity being the first two. An air conditioner actually does two jobs - it lowers the temperature and removes moisture from the air, thus taking care of the first two factors, with HVAC design anyway.
To remove the moisture, however, the air conditioner needs long runtimes. That's because the air moving over the cold evaporator coil causes the water vapor to condense. The
more air moves over the coil, the more water condenses out and gets carried away. It takes about 15 minutes of runtime before you start getting serious dehumidification of the air, so oversized systems will not dehumidify well.
If the AC comes on, runs 10 minutes or less, and then shuts off, the house may be cool, but in a humid climate, the indoor humidity levels will stay high, probably over 60%.
I know this from personal experience. Last year we replaced the AC in our condo, and I did the Manual J load calculation. The result was that we needed a 1.6 ton air conditioner for our 1500 square feet, so we had a 2 ton system installed. Knowing that Manual J has a built-in oversizing bias, I wanted to go with the 1.5 ton system, but I chickened out.
Our AC runs maybe 15 minutes max on a hot afternoon, and our relative humidity stays around 60%. The Manual J bias is real, and it's not small. And that's with an accurate HVAC load calculation. I've seen plenty of load calculations that use incorrect inputs so the contractor can come up with a cooling load to match the AC size he wants to install.
Now, back to the point of this article - how to tell if you have an oversized air conditioner. Just get your stop watch and time how long the AC runs on a hot afternoon. Ten minutes or less, and it's definitely oversized. Twenty minutes would be OK. Thirty minutes at a time or longer, and your humidity levels should be fairly low.
So, how long does your air conditioner run on a hot day?
See my followup article with real data on our AC runtimes:
My Big Fat Oversized Air Conditioner
The Magic of Cold, Part 1 - How Your Air Conditioner Works
3 Reasons Your 3 Ton Air Conditioner Isn't Really 3 Tons